बीमार गायों को क्यों बेच देता है भा. पशु चि. अनु. सं. संस्थान List of Non-Productive and diseased animals (67) sold from Indian Veterinary Research Institute, Izatnagar

List of Non-Productive and diseased animals (67) sold from Indian Veterinary Research Institute, Izatnagar, Bareilly in the year 2011-2014)
The write up is based on the information sought under the RTI Act.
The Data in the table below is for 2014-2018 

I had no intention to publish this list (extracted from the data received from Indian Veterinary Research Institute under RTI), however, as per the statement of Director IVRI ("-------No diseased animal is culled.---"), and other officials in different newspapers (http://inextepaper.jagran.com/1143907/INEXT-BAREILLY/22-03-17#page/2/2, http://epaper.jagran.com/ePaperArticle/22-mar-2017-edition-Bareilly-Nagar-page_4-12860-8370-147.html, http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/bareilly/scientist-alleges-ivri-sold-cows-to-butchers-tweets-to-pmo/articleshowprint/57783632.cms), it appears that wants to prove that the information shared by me on my blog (https://azad-azadindia.blogspot.in/), tweet (@brs1762)  and Facebook (Bhoj R Singh) is not true. So for proof, I am putting here the list of 67 animals auctioned by the Indian Veterinary Research Institute during the year 2011-14. You all are wise enough to judge the statement issued by the Director. They say that the auction only non-productive animals, what is the fate of non-productive cows, does anybody not know. Do people are buying non-productive cows to worship them, or do the purchasers belong to some Gaushala, Gausadan? How many Gausadans/ Gaushalas are run by Muslims? Do the Muslims, those who purchased almost 72% of cows from IVRI, represent any Gaushala or own Gaushalas? Their fate is undoubtedly illegal slaughter and who is providing cows for illegal slaughter, none but the premiere institute mandated to serve the animals. Is this the only way by which we will double the income of farmers in the coming years? 

भा. पशु चि. अनु. सं. संस्थान इज्जत नगर बरेली से नीलाम की गई बीमार और अनुत्पादक गौधन की सूची

मेरा कोई उद्देश्य इस सूची को छापने का नहीं था परंतु मेरे ब्लॉग ((https://azad-azadindia.blogspot.in/)), ट्विटर (@brs1762) एवं फेस बुक (Bhoj R Singh) पर छापे पोस्ट को संस्थान के निदेशक एवं अन्य पदाधिकारियों ने विभिन्न समाचार पत्रों में ये कहकर खारिज़ किया है (http://inextepaper.jagran.com/1143907/INEXT-BAREILLY/22-03-17#page/2/2, http://epaper.jagran.com/ePaperArticle/22-mar-2017-edition-Bareilly-Nagar-page_4-12860-8370-147.html, http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/bareilly/scientist-alleges-ivri-sold-cows-to-butchers-tweets-to-pmo/articleshowprint/57783632.cms) कि वे कोई बीमार पशु नहीं बेचते.

सच्चाई आपके सामने है स्वयं देखिये किस सच्चाई के साथ देश सेवा कर रहे हैं संस्थान के पदाधिकारी. सूची आपके सामने है.

संस्थान के पदाधिकारी कहते हैं कि वे अनुत्पादक पशुओं को बेचते हैं. तो क्या अनुत्पादक गायों को लोग संस्थान से पूजा के लिए खरीदते हैं? संस्थान से लगभग ७२% गायों के खरीदार मुस्लिम समुदाय के हैं, ये अच्छी बात है कि अब यह कम्युनिटी गायों कि पूजा करने लगी है. देश में कितनी गौशालाएं (या गौसदन) मुस्लिम लोगों द्वारा चलाई जा रही हैं जो वहां ये गायें खरीदकर पाली जा रही हैं? क्या खरीदार कोई गौसेवा केंद्र चलाते हैं या किसी गौशाला के नुमाइंदे हैं या थे? प्रश्न बहुत से हैं परंतु मेरी उन्हें पूछने के हैसियत नहीं है.

क्या इसी तरह से आने वाले वर्षो में किसानों और पशुपालकों कि आय दुगना की जानी है.

List of Non-Productive and diseased animals (67) sold from Indian Veterinary Research Institute, Izatnagar, Bareilly in the year 2011-2014)

Auctioned Diseased and Non-productive Tharparkar Cows auctioned
Year	S.N.	Stock No.	Sex	Disease	Comment
2010-11	55	7	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	62	19	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	64	22	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	72	33	Female	Lameness
2010-11	79	50	Female	Chronic disease	Everybody knows which is chronic diseases (TB/ JD)
2010-11	81	53	Female	Weakness Debility	Probably some chronic diseases
2010-11	87	61	Female	Prolapse
2010-11	100	77	Female	Lameness
2011-12	267	41	Female	Stillbirth	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2011-12	268	46	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2011-12	302	92	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2013-14	678	257	Female	Stillbirth	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2014-15	870	298	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2014-15	877	323	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
Auctioned Diseased and Nonproductive Other cows
2010-11	9	427	Female	Old  age	Useless
2010-11	11	491	Female	Debility	Probably some chronic diseases
2010-11	14	540	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	15	550	Female	Fibrosed udder
2010-11	30	873	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	34	909	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	39	930	Female	Anaoestrous	Not able to conceive
2010-11	62	940	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	65	1084	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	66	1096	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	67	1110	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	79	1551	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	94	311	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	100	588	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	103	676	Female	Debility	Probably some chronic diseases
2010-11	110	879	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	111	913	Female	Debility	Probably some chronic diseases
2010-11	129	1305	Female	Fibrosed teats
2010-11	173	1049	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	200	514	Male	Surplus
2010-11	385	173	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2010-11	391	210	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2013-14	19	1134	Female	Stillbirth	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2013-14	210	509	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2013-14	232	618	Female	Stillbirth	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2011-12	593	882	Female	Udder wound and Weak
2011-12	597	929	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2011-12	598	931	Female	Left hindquarter teat blind
2011-12	607	183	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2011-12	610	516	Female	Blind teat
2011-12	615	905	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2011-12	619	1204	Female	Persistent anoestrous
2011-12	622	1431	Female	Blind teat
2011-12	640	755	Female	Repeat Breeder	Not able to conceive
2011-12	729	88	Male	Abnormal testes
2011-12	747	856	Male	Surplus
2011-12	964	384	Female	Stillbirth	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2011-12	986	453	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2011-12	987	455	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2011-12	1017	556	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease
2011-12	1038	611	Female	Brucellosis	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2012-13	1284	928	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2012-13	1457	182	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2012-13	1475	367	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2014-15	182	555	Female	Brucellosis	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
Auctioned Diseased and Nonproductive Buffaloes
2010-11	538	347	Female	Repeat breeder	Not able to conceive
2010-11	592	694	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2010-11	636	773	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2010-11	666	803	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2011-12	859	345	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2014-15	1596	966	Female	Brucellosis	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2014-15	1609	1035	Female	Brucellosis	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)
2014-15	1612	1046	Female	Abortion	Major cause of stillbirths and abortion in Indian Veterinary Research Institute is Brucellosis (a zoonotic communicable disease)

Besides this list, three cow bulls not fit for breeding were also sold (not to mention to whom) from the Institute. For what use?
Year of auction   Animal stock number

2010-11	88	1561
2011-12	704	969
2011-12	706	1027

Dear friends, I have received the Show Cause Notice in the evening of the yesterday (23-03-2017)from the IVRI Administration for revealing the above truth recovered from data provided by the same Institute after charging about Rs. 5000 as xeroxing charges.
1. Does revealing the truth is a crime? 
2. Does the information received under RTI Act 2005 should be kept in bank locker?
3. Do we need any permission to share the information received under RTI.
4. Does truth be defamatory? (except in the case of untruthful people).
5. What is your Opinion please share for my guidance. So that in the future I may not repeat any mistakes.

Dear Friends

Auction of diseased and non-productive cows from the Indian Veterinary Research Institute, is a crime under the following acts and rules have been violated

1.    The U.P. Prevention of Cow Slaughter Act, 1955. (U.P. Act No. 1 of 1956) and U.P. Govadh Nivaran Niyamavali, 1964.

2.    Animal Transport Act (1429/2006) and Transport of Animals, Rules, 1978

3.    The Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960

And the sale of milk and milk products from Brucellosis and TB positive herds to the public without informed advisory is a violation of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2


News links:
1. https://www.pressreader.com/india/the-times-of-india-new-delhi-edition/20170323/282011852183261
2. http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/bareilly/scientist-alleges-ivri-sold-cows-to-butchers-tweets-to-pmo/articleshow/57783632.cms
3. http://epaperbeta.timesofindia.com/Article.aspx?eid=31804&articlexml=IVRI-sells-cows-to-butchers-says-scientist-23032017013024
4. https://legendnews.in/ivri-senior-scientist-allegations-government-institute-cow-selling-is-butchers/
5. गौहत्या में भारतीय पशु चिकित्सा अनुसन्धान संस्थान का योगदान: फरीदपुर चौधरी से गौकशी (Cowslaughter) के अपराध में कल गिरफ्तार किये गए चारों कसाई हैं भारतीय पशु चिकित्सा अनुसन्धान संस्थान से बिकने वाली गायों के बड़े खरीदार. Role of IVRI in Cow Slaughter: The four persons (Anish, Nadeem, Safeeque, Subhan) arrested yesterday for slaughtering cow are the biggest purchasers of cows auctioned from Indian Veterinary Research Institute. http://epaper.livehindustan.com/imageview_109290_111654496_4_22_02-07-2019_i_1.pagezoomsinwindows.php

http://epaper.livehindustan.com/imageview_109293_111526660_4_22_02-07-2019_i_4.pagezoomsinwindows.php